An in depth look at the role and rights of juries in the american justice system
Even though the grand jury work is secret, federal rules and a majority of states permit grand jury witnesses to discuss what occurred when they testified. Jurors should not discuss the case with any person other than members of the jury.
In some cases, like the Russia investigation, prosecutors do not have all the evidence they need to make a good case. A landmark empirical study of the rates of agreement and disagreement, and their reasons, between jury verdicts and what the trial judge would have decided absent the jury.
The jury does not interpret the law. Justice System. Hall, Kermit. In reaching its verdict in a criminal trialthe jury must be satisfied that the person is guilty beyond reasonable doubt.
Where does the right to a jury come from
Not every time, of course, they are not infallible — how could they be, no humans are, not even judges, but they do get it right most of the time. Maxwell, U. Hans and Vidmar, What last week's report shows beyond reasonable doubt is that is exactly what juries do and, for all our sakes, they must be allowed to carry on doing it. In the U. In some cases, like the Russia investigation, prosecutors do not have all the evidence they need to make a good case. A landmark empirical study of the rates of agreement and disagreement, and their reasons, between jury verdicts and what the trial judge would have decided absent the jury. Court clerks first identify members of the grand jury pool from public records, including records of licensed drivers and registered voters. These difficult issues about the operation of the legal system are not easily resolved, nor are they entirely new. Recent studies have found that in urban jurisdictions, 20 percent or more of the citizenry who receive jury summons fail to report to the courthouse for potential service. As witness testimony, attorney arguments, and trials have become longer and more complex, however, a variety of measures designed to enhance the performance of juries have been debated and often enacted. Interview a parent or some other adult who was called for jury service. Did this person: Serve on a jury? Key Jury Decisions of the U.
Constitution provides the legal basis for grand juries. The work of a grand jury is required by law to be done in secret, so the public has no right to know who is subpoenaed or what documents the grand jury is reviewing. They may keep a copy of the indictment, the exhibits and their notes.
In order to understand grand juries and their work, I offer the following explanation of how federal and state grand juries are used in the U. New York: Times Books, How many people serve on a petit jury? It attempts to measure progress in the jury as a democratic institution against critiques as to ways in which the system falls short and could be improved.
Role of the jury in a criminal trial
Did you know that until , women did not serve on juries in Alabama, Mississippi, and South Dakota, and that women became eligible for jury service in all federal and state courts only in ? Interview a parent or some other adult who was called for jury service. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press, Kentucky, U. Berkeley, Calif. Order online at www. When a jury consists of more than 12 members, only 12 are selected to consider the verdict. A Court Garda or other official is required to keep the jury together until the verdict is reached. A jury that includes African Americans will presumably be better able to understand the circumstances of an African American defendant who claims to have been targeted by police, just as a jury that includes women will likely be better able to understand the experience of a woman charged with assault against an abusive husband.
based on 11 review